"Beware of Warranty Deeds
That Can Marry You for Life"
By Marian L. Faupel
Unmarried heterosexual couples and gay couples often buy property
together. In routine transactions, the only people who study the closing
documents are the title company and the Realtors. Unfortunately, a major
problem can develop if property is conveyed to the couple as "joint
tenants with full rights of survivorship."
"Joint tenants with full rights of survivorship" means that when one of
the owners dies, the other owner inherits the entire interest in the
property. This passes outside of any probate court, so this result
overrides any provision in a will or trust to the contrary.
"Tenants in common," on the other hand, are owners who hold their
interest in the property as if it were a separate asset. This "undivided
one half" interest can be sold, mortgaged, or bequeathed in a will. When
either of the owners dies, that owner’s estate inherits the interest in
the property. This may result in the other owner’s now being forced to
deal with a stranger -- or even an enemy in some strained families.
When couples are engaged in a harmonious relationship, they may think
that they in fact want to be joint tenants with full rights of
survivorship. The problem, however, is that in Michigan, the courts have
held that they do not have the jurisdiction to partition this
relationship or end it. If one were married and this were the "marital
home," then the judge would have jurisdiction under the divorce
laws to distribute the property to one of the parties or order it sold.
In the absence of a marriage, however, this sort of jurisdiction
does not exist. What happens then is that if the couple has a falling
out and separates, neither of them will be able to force a sale of the
property. Meanwhile, the parties remain liable on a mortgage they now
may regret.
The solution is to hold the property as "tenants in common." You have to
look at your deed to find out what you are now if you are in this
situation. The deed will have the words "joint tenants with full rights
of survivorship" after your name if that is what you are. If the deed
just has your names on it without any further designation, then you
already are tenants in common under the law because that is the
presumption for unmarried people. (It is actually reversed for married
couples because the law assumes that they want to be joint tenants with
full rights of survivorship.)
If you are a joint tenant with full rights of survivorship, this form of
ownership can be changed by having both you and your partner
execute a quit claim deed conveying the property to yourselves as
tenants in common. You can then execute a will that leaves the
individual interests in the property to each other in the case of death.
If there is a falling out, either party can revoke his/her will. This is
easy to do.
Strangely enough, married couples can be sure that a divorce court will
divide and/or distribute any marital property as part of the
proceedings. Unmarried couples seldom suspect that if they break up, no
court will be able to assist them under current law. In this respect,
the wrong kind of deed can literally marry you for life! |